June 19, 2025

Another big beautiful benefit for the wealthy in the Big Beautiful bill

Sludge -  You’re likely aware of some of the big-ticket tax benefits for wealthy individuals and companies in the GOP’s budget reconciliation bill now moving through Congress, but buried in it is another tax provision that’s raising some alarms: the bill would create an unprecedented new tax shelter that could let billionaires save millions in taxes through donations to private school voucher funds, all paid for by the public. 

The Educational Choice for Children Act, included in the sprawling tax and spending package, would allow individuals to claim a 100% tax credit for donations to nonprofits that distribute K-12 school vouchers. Unlike a typical deduction for a charitable donation, this credit would reimburse donors dollar-for-dollar, effectively making the federal government cover the entire donation. No other kind of charities—such as disaster relief organizations, food banks, or medical assistance groups—receive this level of tax incentive from the federal government. The Senate’s version of the bill would cap the program at $4 billion in credits per year, starting in 2027.

Beyond the credit, tax experts say that donors could even profit off the provision through excess tax liability savings. Donors could give appreciated stock instead of cash, allowing them to avoid the capital gains tax while also getting full reimbursement from the federal government, effectively reducing their tax liability beyond what their donation actually cost them. An analysis by the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy (ITEP) estimates the provision would cost the federal government $134 billion over the next decade, while only generating about $126 billion in actual contributions to school voucher programs and providing $10.5 billion in personal profit to wealthy donors in the form of capital gains tax avoidance. 

No comments: