May 4, 2015

Word: What steady state supporters and peacemakers have in common

Link corrected

Herman Daley - International “free trade pacts” (NAFTA, TPP, TAFTA) are supposed to increase global GDP, thereby making us all richer and effectively expanding the size of the earth and easing conflict. But growth in the full world has become uneconomic–increasing costs faster than benefits. It now makes us poorer, not richer. These secretly negotiated agreements among the elites are designed to benefit private global corporations, often at the expense of the public good of nations.

Some think that strengthening global corporations by erasing national boundaries will reduce the likelihood of war. More likely we will just shift to feudal corporate wars in a post-national global commons, with corporate fiefdoms effectively buying national governments and their armies, supplemented by already existing private mercenaries.

It is hard to imagine a steady state economy without peace; it is hard to imagine peace in a full world without a steady state economy. Those who work for peace are promoting the steady state, and those who work for a steady state are promoting peace. This implicit alliance needs to be made explicit. Contrary to popular belief, growth in a finite and full world is not the path to peace, but to further conflict. It is an illusion to think that we can buy peace with growth. The growth economy and warfare are now natural allies. It is time for peacemakers and steady staters to recognize their natural alliance.

It would be naïve, however, to think that growth in the face of environmental limits is the only cause of war. Evil ideologies, religious conflict, and “clash of civilizations” also cause wars. National defense is necessary, but uneconomic growth does not make our country stronger. The secular west has a hard time understanding that religious conviction can motivate people to both to kill and die for their beliefs. Modern devotion to the Secular God of Growth, who promises heaven on earth, has itself become a fanatical religion that inspires violence as much as any ancient Moloch. The Second Commandment, forbidding the worship of false gods (idolatry) is not outdated. Our modern idols are new versions of Mammon and Mars.

2 comments:

Capt. America said...

Free trade has always caused war. The elites blame poverty and joblessness on other countries until the hate explodes into war, over and over, again and again.

And evil ideologies are of no danger whatever until they are fostered and financed by evil, greedy, corrupt, and cynical elites, as ISIS, Al Qaeda, Hezbollah, and the "Palestinians" have been reared and funded.

Greg Gerritt said...

For the last 15 years I have used as my tag line
"You can not heal ecosystems without ending poverty, you can not end poverty without healing ecosystems. And yo9u will not do any of it if we do not shut down the war machine.

Herman Daly does great work.