UNDERNEWS: Michael Moore's controversial new film on the environment

April 28, 2020

Michael Moore's controversial new film on the environment

We haven't seen the film, but while we have been one of the few progressive journals noting the usually unmentioned role of population growth in ecological crises, and see this - along with obsession with economic growth - as an important negative matter, we don't think attacking ecologists for their other choices makes much sense.

We do agree with director Jeff Gibbs who said, "I think many young people realize that growth itself – perpetual economic growth on a finite planet is essentially suicide, and that we have to find a different model for how we measure growth, happiness and prosperity."

This does not have to be in place of current environmentalism but in significant addition to it.

The controversy

2 comments:

amaranth farm said...: It should be required watching. 15 years ago I was writing newspapers and congress critters on the inextricable link between "green" means of energy and fossil fuels. Also the madness of infinite growth on a finite planet. I have written Mckibbon on his hipocracy. I have written you and him on the toxicity of Lithium Ion batteries. Our collective denial of death is too great to make a dent in even the discussion of our situation.

That denial is laid out in detail in what should also be required reading for any human:

https://www.worldcat.org/title/denial-of-death/oclc/658905; April 28, 2020 at 5:49 PM
Greg Gerritt said...: I watched most of it. it says many things about the environmental movement that are just untrue. in Maine we opposed biomass strongly back in the 1990's. it was a big reaason we tried to ban clearcutting.

it also uses a lot of out of date information.; April 28, 2020 at 9:01 PM

Post a Comment

ABOUT THE EDITOR

The Review is edited by Sam Smith, who covered Washington under nine presidents, has edited the Progressive Review and its predecessors since 1964, wrote four books, been published in five anthologies, helped to start five organizations (including the DC Humanities Council and the DC Statehood Party), was a plaintiff in three successful class action suits, served as a Coast Guard officer, and played in jazz bands for four decades.

A truly independent journalist with his feet firmly grounded in the reality of neighborhoods and everyday people. -- Patrick Mazza, Progressive Populist

A truly original voice in American journalism: humorous and plain spoken and filled with common sense -- Jay Walljasper, Utne Reader

Inimitable -- Mother Jones Magazine

Sam's a cynical cat -- Marion Barry

Sam's one of the few independent voices left. The press today is either extreme or special interest or else just establishment, an extension of the corporate spirit -- Sen. Eugene McCarthy,

One of a small group of whites with whom many blacks would trust their political lives - Chuck Stone, Washingtonian.

A reputation for wit, intelligence and anger. -- Claude Lewis, Chicago Tribune

Smith is an island of reason and information in a sea of narcissistic blather. -- City Paper, Washington

Whatever the debate, the Review's sharp critiques encourage us to look out our window, notice and act upon what we see, and also to look further -- to the rest of the country and globe -- to see how the organized big world interacts with our more spontaneous small worlds. - Utne Reader