Intercept - Two doctors who met privately with Hillary Clinton during the 1993 health reform debate say she agreed that single-payer healthcare would be good for Americans. Their recollections raise questions about both the motive and the sincerity of Clinton’s recent assault on Democratic presidential rival Bernie Sanders for supporting such a system.
Until Clinton’s pivot, the accepted Democratic view was that single-payer was the best solution in theory, but that it was politically unrealistic. Clinton’s new critiques, by contrast, are an attempt to make Sanders’s single-payer proposals sound costly and destructive.
NY Times, 2006 - As she runs for re-election to the Senate from New York this year and lays the groundwork for a possible presidential bid in 2008, Mrs. Clinton is receiving hundreds of thousands of dollars in campaign contributions from doctors, hospitals, drug manufacturers and insurers. Nationwide, she is the No. 2 recipient of donations from the industry, trailing only Senator Rick Santorum of Pennsylvania, a member of the Republican leadership.
Smith, Shadows of Hope, 1993 - During the first months of the
Clinton administration, one of the biggest national policy changes
of the past fifty years was being forged by a secret committee
led by Mrs. Clinton under procedures that periodically defied
the courts and the Government Accounting Office and whose public
manifestations consisted of highly contrived media opportunities,
carefully staged "town meetings," and similar artifices.
the contrary evidence of public opinion polls, the concept of
Canadian-style single-payer insurance was dismissed early. Tom
Hamburger and Ted Marmor in the Washington Monthly tell of a
single-payer proponent being invited to the White House in February
1993. It was, he said, a "pseudo-consultation;" the
doctor was quickly informed that "single payer is not politically
feasible." When Dr. David Himmelstein of the Harvard Medical
School pressed Mrs. Clinton on single payer, she replied, "Tell
me something interesting, David."
words, write Hamburger and Marmor: "Fewer than six weeks
into the Clinton presidency, the White House had made its key
policy decision: Before the Health Care Task Force wrote a single
page of its 22-volume report to the President, the single payer
idea was written off, and "managed competition" was
was any popular, grassroots demand for "managed competition"
it never appeared. Managed competition had not been tested anywhere.
Nonetheless, reported Thomas Bodenehimer in Nation:
Hillary Rodham Clinton's health reform table sit the managed-competition
winners: big business, hospitals, large (but not small) commercial
insurers, the Blues, budget-worried government leaders and the
'Jackson Hole Group,' the chief intellectual honchos of the managed
competition movement. . . Adherence to the mantra of managed
competition appears to be the price of a ticket of admission
to this gathering. "
finally proposed involved a massive transfer of the American
health industry - by some accounts now larger than the military-industrial
complex - to a small number of the largest insurance companies
and other major corporations. These were companies that had the
assets to play the game being offered - a medical oligopoly that
would dispense health-care under the rules of the Fortune 500
rather than according to those of Hipprocrates.
Snow, 1994 -
[HRC] set out to redesign the American health-care system and
convened a panel that drafted its plan secretly -- in violation
of federal law .... The plan prescribed some eye- popping maximum
fines: $5,000 for refusing to join the government- mandated health
plan; $5,000 for failing to pay premiums on time; 15 years to
doctors who received "anything of value" in exchange
for helping patients short-circuit the bureaucracy; $10,000 a
day for faulty physician paperwork; $50,000 for unauthorized
patient treatment; and $100,000 a day for drug companies that
messed up federal filings .... When told the plan could bankrupt
small businesses, Mrs. Clinton sighed, "I can't be responsible
for every undercapitalized small business in America." When
a woman complained that she didn't want to get shoved into a
plan not of her choosing, the first lady lectured, "It's
time to put the common good, the national interest, ahead of
individuals." As for privacy, forget it: Her plan would
have required people to carry national identification cards that
embedded confidential patient information on computer chips.
A federal judge issued a fine for a quarter million
dollars because, "The Executive Branch of the government,
working in tandem, was dishonest with this court." At issue
is the composition of Hillary Clinton's health task force, a
body stacked with those from the medical industry who would gain
most from its faux reforms.