June 6, 2012

Morning Line: Why people vote against themselves

Sam Smith

It is always sad to see large numbers of people engaged in a politics that opposes their true self interest.

It is one of the things that defined the American south for a century after the Civil War.

It was what allowed the Nazis to take power in Germany.

And it is what happened  in Wisconsin's recall election.

The reasons are numerous and varied but key to them is often a culture under great stress believing false promises being made to it by the powerful. White southern sharecroppers were taught to romanticize a plantation society they could never join and to blame blacks for their problems. For Germans the target was Jews and for Wisconsinites it was public unions.

While the scale and ultimate evil of these examples differ enormously, the strategy was the same: false stories, false demons and false solutions.

It is, however, the reality that Wisconsin faced badly and which greater America will face in coming months, so it may help to look at some other important factors affecting the state's outcome:

Money:. The right spent about $23 a vote to win in Wisconsin. Transferred to the fall election, that would mean - thanks to the despicable Citizens United ruling - any of the following could buy the election and still have  from 83 to 98 percent of their wealth left: Bill Gates, Warren Buffet, either of the Koch brothers, Geoge Soros, any of four Waltons, Michael Bloomberg or Mark Zuckerberg.

The media - Television remains the major source of information and misinformation for American families, who spend over six hours a day with their TVs on. The networks they are watching are overwhelmingly run by corporations whose bias is towards the right. To get a sense of how television affects our view of politics, notice how often TV journalists refer to a candidate's ads as opposed to their actual positions. TV has made political propaganda equal to or superior to actual facts in its coverage. This doesn't even have to be malicious. For example, last night Howard Fineman on MSNBC was pushing the Republican line that public employee pensions are a serious issue. If Fineman had bothered to look into the matter he would have found, as Robert Reich has reported, that "public-sector workers now earn 11 percent less than comparable workers in the private sector, and local workers 12 percent less. (Even if you include health and retirement benefits, government employees still earn less than their private-sector counterparts with similar educations.)" These days it is considered good journalism just to pass on the lies of politicians.

Extremist group culture - The secret of extremist groups is that they offer salvation with little demanded other than cash and loyalty. The Republican Party is increasingly sharing the characteristics of the KKK, the Church of Scientology or Skull & Bones, namely offering a safe haven without the need for thought.This has a powerful appeal to the troubled.

The collapse of civic education: One of the seldom discussed characteristics of corporate-driven school testing is that it takes major time away from those former activities in a school that made students good citizens able to function with others. The victims include not only civic education but joint activities - including the performing arts - that teach the young how to live in a community. Another victim is history. Where does a young person today learn about the role labor unions have played in making America the country it is? Or come to  understand the importance of a recall?:

The significance of this in Wisconsin was well described by Daily Kos: "Young people didn't turn out. Only 16 percent of the electorate was 18-29, compared to 22 percent in 2008. That's the difference between 646,212 and 400,599 young voters, or about 246,000. Walker won by 172,739 votes."

Labor unions - Labor unions aren't what they once were, not because the problems that created them don't still exist but; like so many other American institutions. they have become more often iconic instruments of power rather than effective advocates and practitioners of their own cause.  Unions have been losing members for quite a while, yet - with a few notable exceptions - not much imagination has been applied to the problem. For example, the labor movement could have launched a workers' equivalent of the AARP, one of the powerful non profits in the country - creating its own constituency for organizing. Unfortunately, nothing like this happened.

The collapse of liberalism - In recent decades, liberalism has turned into a upscale social demographic rather than a political movement. As it has done so, its historic connections with the working class and labor have suffered badly. For example, Franklin Roosevelt's labor secretary, Frances Perkins, was central to more progressive economic legislation than the entire liberal movement has been able to come up with in the past thirty years. It's hard to get liberals excited anymore about issues like pensions or the minimum wage and eventually politics reflects this fact. Consider the example of the women's movement, which - with a few exceptions like the group Nine to Five - has been stunningly uninvolved with the most oppressed women in the country, those of lower incomes and social class. Further, treating those you should be organizing as just a bunch of  Bible thumping, gun toting idiots doesn't help much.

To be sure, not much of the above can be cured by November, but it may help to face a few of these facts head on and then start doing something about them.


Strelnikov said...

Scientology is collapsing....hopefully the GOP follows.

Samson said...

For a political strategist on the pro-recall side, what of the above should have been a surprise.

That the Koch Brothers have more money than a grassroots movement?

That our 'news' comes from Wall Street's media arm, and thus favors the rich and promotes union-busting?

That there are crazies on the extremes of both left and right?

That our education system has been attacked for 40 years, and these days there is next to nothing in any post-school education on how to be a citizen in a democracy?

That labor unions aren't as strong as they used to be?

That liberalism died when Tip O'Niell struggled and lost against Ronald Reagan, and that today's Democrats basically line up from Reagan to the further right?

My point is that none of these are a reason to lose. They are a part of our political landscape. But I'm tired of watching incompetent politics from the left followed by a series of lame excuses.

We know we'll be outspent. That's why we must focus on grassroots power.

We know the media is our enemy, which why we must isolate them and provide our own information. Likewise we know our education system teaches little about citizenship, and nothing at all about how people can organize and assert their power ... all of which is why we must teach them this.

And most of all, we know the powerful are not on our side. This includes labor bosses who want to preserve their cushy 6-figure jobs and most of all the pro-corporate, pro-Wall Street democrats who view us only as someone to be robbed by their robber-baron friends.

The article lists the political environment in which we must operate. But nothing in there says we must lose.

Anonymous said...

Valid points by Sam, and comments. I don't see him excusing the loss, but diagnosing it.

I think the boneheaded approach of labor figures largely in this defeat. It's their iron in the fire, but they chose spending big money in the electoral system on a Democrat - a loser's trifecta. Not getting it right in their own defense makes it that much harder for their supporters.

Flip said...

You said little about Ron Paul except posted an article that was clearly an attack accusing him of racism.
So now you claim you will vote Obama because Romney is not acceptable.
We could have turned things around with Paul but instead you helped Romney.
Obama again because no choice.
Obama sucks.

Anonymous said...

Hello, this weekend is fastidious in favor of me, because this point in time i am reading this fantastic educational article here at my house.